A few years back I read about a store in Manhattan that sold only rice pudding and I wondered how anyone could just eat rice pudding day in and day out? Well, that’s the same feeling I got when I noticed the new Schulzies in San Francisco’s Hayes Valley, which sells only bread pudding.

Scooped up into balls like ice cream, these light bread pudding in various flavors – things like Millie Vanillie Bean, Blissed Out Blueberry, Coconut Cove and simply Whisky – are the creation of Sarah Schulz, who opened her first bread pudding parlor in Venice in Southern California.

But apparently Schulz is originally from San Francisco so she decided to open her second location in her hometown, in a tiny spot in the trendy Hayes Valley that used to be a mini café. It actually took awhile for the place to open, but it finally did in late January.

Curious Onlookers
People walking by the store often do a double-take when they see the words “bread pudding” on the signs. Those who venture in to try one will pay $4.50 for a single scoop and $6.50 for double scoop.

After brunch with my friend Craig, we tried some bread pudding for dessert. Craig was smart and got a scoop of the Whisky flavor. I think it’s smart with a typically heavy dessert like bread pudding to spice it up with liquor. He enjoyed it.

I got a scoop of salted caramel and another scoop of lemon. There are toppings that you can add for no additional charge, but I played it safe and simply added a squirt of caramel sauce.

The Verdict
While the overall feel of the bread pudding was light, it did have a texture that reminded me of overcooked oatmeal. It’s not very sweet, and while the lemon flavor was nice, I barely tasted salted caramel in the other scoop. In fact, they were very similar.

While it was a warm day, the bread pudding was lukewarm, and not very cold, so when competing with ice cream, I think I would get a scoop of ice cream instead. Still, the novelty of it all continues to draw people to Schulzies. It might not be for me, but if you’re a fan of bread pudding, then you’ll find your heaven in Schulzies.

Schulzies, 364 Hayes St. (between Gough and Franklin), San Francisco. PH: 415.565.7336. Open daily from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. www.schulziesbreadpudding.com

Bread pudding getting scooped up like ice cream

Bread pudding getting scooped up like ice cream

The flavor board. Yes, there's more than one flavor of bread pudding. I liked the one called "Warm"

The flavor board. Yes, there’s more than one flavor of bread pudding. I liked the one called “Warm”

While it's novel to see some many different flavors of bread pudding, it wasn't really for me.

You can top your bread pudding with a bunch of toppings for no additional cost.


2 Responses to Schulzies in San Francisco Sells the Novelty of Bread Pudding

  1. Carolyn Jung says:

    I’ve been to the rice pudding joint in NY: https://www.ricetoriches.com/
    It’s so much fun — has sort of a Jetson’s motif. And the rice pudding is awesome.
    Wow, who knew there was a bread pudding place in SF? Though, I think bread pudding should be served warm. Lukewarm just doesn’t do it justice.

    • Ben Ben says:

      I don’t know how warm bread pudding will go when the weather gets warmer. But then again, we are talking about San Francisco so it’ll probably never get that hot. I think you can request to have them warm up your bread pudding choice, or you can just order the one called “warm.” hehe